Nordmann fir, Norway spruce or Fraser fir: which tree?
Updated October 2026
Most UK farms grow a few main varieties. Here’s how they usually compare. Every tree is different, so look closely at the one in front of you.
Nordmann fir
The UK’s most popular real tree. Soft, glossy, dark green needles that aren’t prickly, and very good needle retention, so it’s a safe choice if you want the tree up for several weeks. The scent is mild. Nordmanns are often a little more expensive than spruce.
Norway spruce
The traditional British Christmas tree, with a strong, classic pine scent and a neat conical shape. The needles are sharper and it drops needles sooner in a warm room, so it suits people who put their tree up later in December and keep it watered.
Fraser fir
A slimmer tree with upward-pointing branches, good for smaller rooms. The needles are soft, hold well, and have a pleasant citrusy scent. Fewer farms grow it than the two above.
Others you might see
- Blue spruce: striking blue-grey colour, very prickly, and good needle retention for a spruce.
- Noble fir: silvery-blue needles and stiff branches that take heavy decorations. Often pricier.
- Pot-grown trees: sold with roots in a pot. With care they can go back outside after Christmas, but they need a cool room and shouldn’t be indoors for long.
Quick comparison
| Needle drop | Scent | Prickly? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nordmann fir | Low | Mild | No |
| Norway spruce | Higher | Strong | Yes |
| Fraser fir | Low | Fresh, citrusy | No |
| Blue spruce | Medium | Mild | Very |
Which varieties a farm grows varies. Where a farm mentions them, we include it on the farm page.
Common questions
Which tree drops the fewest needles?
Nordmann fir is the best-known “non-drop” tree, and Fraser fir also holds its needles well. Norway spruce drops sooner in a warm, dry room.
Which smells the most Christmassy?
Norway spruce and Fraser fir have a stronger scent than Nordmann fir, which is quite mild. If the smell matters, sniff a branch at the farm.
Which is best for pets and children?
Nordmann fir has soft, blunt needles that are kinder to hands and paws. Blue spruce and Norway spruce are sharper. Keep any tree well watered and stable, and keep pets from drinking the stand water.
Why is Nordmann fir more expensive?
It grows more slowly, so it takes longer to reach a saleable size. That’s why it usually costs more than a Norway spruce of the same height.
What our farm data shows
Of the 219 UK farms that name the trees they sell, 155 (71%) sell Nordmann fir, 141 (64%) sell Norway spruce and 72 (33%) sell Fraser fir. So Nordmann and Norway spruce are easy to find, but you may need to look for a Fraser.
Where a farm lists prices for both, the Nordmann is the dearer tree. See what farms charge and every type UK farms sell.