Real or artificial Christmas tree?

Updated October 2026

There’s no single right answer, but a few points come up again and again.

What usually matters most

  • What happens to a real tree afterwards. Analyses of tree footprints, such as those published by the Carbon Trust, point out that a real tree that’s chipped, composted or replanted has a much smaller footprint than one sent to landfill, where it rots and releases methane. Recycling it makes a big difference.
  • How long an artificial tree is used. Artificial trees are usually made from plastic and metal, often shipped a long way. They only compare well if they’re reused for many years; you’ll often see “around ten years” quoted.
  • Travel. Driving a long way to fetch a tree adds to its footprint. A farm near you, or a group trip, helps.

Practical differences

Real treeArtificial tree
Scent and lookNaturalConsistent every year
MessNeedles to sweep upVery little
CostEvery yearUpfront, then free
StorageNoneNeeds space all year
AllergiesSome people react to pollen, mould or sapCan gather dust in storage

Buying local

Buying from a UK farm supports local growers and usually means a fresher tree. Many farms plant new trees each year to replace the ones they sell. Find one near you on our Christmas tree farm pages.

Common questions

Is a real tree better for the environment?

Studies generally find a locally grown real tree that’s recycled or replanted has a lower footprint than an artificial tree used only a few times. An artificial tree used for many years narrows the gap. Buying locally and recycling properly makes the biggest difference.

Are real trees a fire risk?

A dry tree burns easily. A well-watered tree is much less of a risk. Keep it away from fires and heaters, use modern LED lights, and turn them off when you go out or to bed.

What about allergies?

Some people react to the scent, sap or mould on trees. A shake at the farm, a quick rinse and dry outdoors, and a cooler room can help. Nordmann fir has a mild scent.

Can I rent a real tree?

Some farms rent pot-grown trees that go back to the farm after Christmas. See our recycling guide for the farms that mention it.

What our farm data shows

  • Grown locally:152 of the 350 UK farms we’ve checked say they grow their own trees, so a real tree from a farm near you hasn’t travelled far.
  • Living trees:123 sell pot-grown or potted trees, and 7 mention renting a living tree that goes back to the farm.
  • After Christmas:7 farms mention a tree recycling service; see our recycling guide for council options.

More christmas trees guides

What’s on near you, every Thursday

Three ideas for farm days out near you each weekend, picked from farms we’ve checked. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

We’ll email you a link to confirm. Sent with EmailOctopus. How we use your email.